Current:Home > FinanceNebraska’s new law limiting abortion and trans healthcare is argued before the state Supreme Court -TradeWisdom
Nebraska’s new law limiting abortion and trans healthcare is argued before the state Supreme Court
View
Date:2025-04-16 16:39:46
Members of the Nebraska Supreme Court appeared to meet with skepticism a state lawyer’s defense of a new law that combines a 12-week abortion ban with another measure to limit gender-affirming health care for minors.
Assistant Attorney General Eric Hamilton argued Tuesday that the hybrid law does not violate a state constitutional requirement that legislative bills stick to a single subject. But he went further, stating that the case is not one the high court should rule on because it is politically charged and lawmaking is within the sole purview of the Legislature.
“Didn’t that ship sail about 150 years ago?” Chief Justice Mike Heavican retorted.
Hamilton stood firm, insisting the lawsuit presented a “nonjusticiable political question” and that the Legislature “self-polices” whether legislation holds to the state constitution’s single-subject rule.
“This court is allowed to review whether another branch has followed the constitutionally established process, isn’t it?” Justice John Freudenberg countered.
The arguments came in a lawsuit brought last year by the American Civil Liberties Union representing Planned Parenthood of the Heartland, contending that the hybrid law violates the one-subject rule. Lawmakers added the abortion ban to an existing bill dealing with gender-related care only after a proposed six-week abortion ban failed to defeat a filibuster.
The law was the Nebraska Legislature’s most controversial last session, and its gender-affirming care restrictions triggered an epic filibuster in which a handful of lawmakers sought to block every bill for the duration of the session — even ones they supported — in an effort to stymie it.
A district judge dismissed the lawsuit in August, and the ACLU appealed.
ACLU attorney Matt Segal argued Tuesday that the abortion segment of the measure and the transgender health care segment dealt with different subjects, included different titles within the legislation and even had different implementation dates. Lawmakers only tacked on the abortion ban to the gender-affirming care bill after the abortion bill had failed to advance on its own, he said.
Segal’s argument seemed based more on the way the Legislature passed the bill than on whether the bill violates the single-subject law, Justice William Cassel remarked.
But Justice Lindsey Miller-Lerman noted that the high court in 2020 blocked a ballot initiative seeking to legalize medical marijuana after finding it violated the state’s single-subject rule. The court found the initiative’s provisions to allow people to use marijuana and to produce it were separate subjects.
If producing medical marijuana and using it are two different topics, how can restricting abortion and transgender health care be the same subject, she asked.
“What we’ve just heard are attempts to shoot the moon,” Segal said in a rebuttal, closing with, “These are two passing ships in the night, and all they have in common is the sea.”
The high court will make a ruling on the case at a later date.
veryGood! (3)
Related
- The Grammy nominee you need to hear: Esperanza Spalding
- Sophie Turner Reunites With Taylor Swift for a Girls' Night Out After Joe Jonas Lawsuit
- Back at old job, Anthony Mackie lends star power to New Orleans’ post-Ida roof repair effort
- In her final game, Julie Ertz helps USWNT regain its joy after World Cup heartbreak
- Buckingham Palace staff under investigation for 'bar brawl'
- Energy Department announces $325M for batteries that can store clean electricity longer
- Who’s Bob Menendez? New Jersey’s senator charged with corruption has survived politically for years
- GOP candidate challenging election loss in race to lead Texas’ most populous county drops lawsuit
- Biden administration makes final diplomatic push for stability across a turbulent Mideast
- Fall in Love With Amazon's Best Deals on the Top-Rated Flannels
Ranking
- 'Squid Game' without subtitles? Duolingo, Netflix encourage fans to learn Korean
- On the sidelines of the U.N.: Hope, cocktails and efforts to be heard
- UGG Tazz Restock: Where to Buy TikTok's Fave Sold-Out Shoe
- Ex-New Mexico sheriff’s deputy facing federal charges in sex assault of driver after crash
- Juan Soto to be introduced by Mets at Citi Field after striking record $765 million, 15
- Which UAW plants are on strike? The 38 GM, Stellantis locations walking out Friday
- A shooting in a pub in Sweden has killed 2 men and wounded 2 more, police say.
- Migrants arriving on US streets share joy, woes: Reporter's notebook
Recommendation
Why members of two of EPA's influential science advisory committees were let go
A shooting in a pub in Sweden has killed 2 men and wounded 2 more, police say.
A shooting in a pub in Sweden has killed 2 men and wounded 2 more, police say.
The Bling Ring’s Alleged Leader Rachel Lee Revisits Infamous Celebrity Crime Case in New Documentary
Alex Murdaugh’s murder appeal cites biased clerk and prejudicial evidence
Book bans continue to rise in US public schools, libraries: 'Attacks on our freedom'
How FDA's top vaccines official is timing his COVID booster and flu shot for fall 2023
Lizzo and her wardrobe manager sued by former employee alleging harassment, hostile work environment